Skip to content

Sivin Kit's Garden

Planting Seeds for a Better World

Menu
  • About
  • Church
  • Disclaimer
  • Education
  • Writing
Menu

Friends in Conversation on “Palestine and Israel” Part II

Posted on 19 January, 200920 January, 2009 by Sivin Kit

image

The news of the ceasefire is provides some relief but does not mean the whole conflict is resolved. We continue with the conversation on “Palestine and Israel” which started in a previous post.

* * *

Thanks, Bro.Pro-accuracy & Engaged Re-framer,

I’m adding some other friends on our email list since they seems to be "thinking Christians" who are in support of Israel in the current conflict.

I think I was not clear enough in my original email to both of you. I actually lean towards replacement theology (the idea that the Church is now the Israel of God and the physical Israel is no longer the Chosen People of God, but are another people group that need to receive Christ to be saved.)

And, even if replacement theology is false, reading through Jeremiah, Lamentations and Ezekiel (as I have been doing the last few months) you get the clear sense that you are allowed to criticize and oppose the Israel that is truly the Chosen People of God if they are not following God properly.

So, I have no argument with that, unlike a lot of Christians who blindly support Israel.
What I was trying to get a handle on is, is it true that the blame for the current crisis rests on Israel, as the Muslim and Malaysian press claim?

Or, is it true that that the Arab states actually are deliberately perpetuating the misery of the Palestinians in order to make Israel look bad? Is it true that Israel actually tries its best to avoid civilian casualties and it is Hamas that deliberately uses civilians as human shields so that they will have lots of dead babies to use as propaganda?

God bless,
    Perplexed Inquirer

* * *

Thanks Bro. Pro-accuracy for your clear reply.  BTW, Perplexed Inquirer you can get the book "Whose Holy City?" by Colin Chapman http://www.amazon.com/Whose-Holy-City-Jerusalem-Future/dp/0801065569 locally in Malaysia.  I think he gives a useful overview on the history as well as possible ways to respond as Christians.

* * *

Perplexed Inquirer wrote:

I think I was not clear enough in my original email to you . I actually lean towards replacement theology (the idea that the Church is now the Israel of God and the physical Israel is no longer the Chosen People of God, but are another people group that need to receive Christ to be saved.)

P.S. I strongly suspect that replacement theology is so commonly denounced these days because of an over-reaction against the abuses of the past, where this was used as one of the justifications for the abuse of Jews. I am strongly against abuse of any people, but that doesn’t mean we must change something which the Bible says just because people misused it to justify the evil they do.

From what I have read, replacement theology was the standard theology of most if not all the early Christian apologists.

Replacement theology is not the same as antisemitism, though antisemites did use it for their purposes.

* * *

Thanks Perplexed Inquirer for keeping the conversation going. 

As your latest email alluded to there will be a variety of views on the place and role of Israel in the light of Christ and the formation of the church and depending on which Eschatological view one takes.

I take the view similar to the late Lesslie Newbigin in that the election of Israel as well as the election of the Church is for the sake of others.  Or some would say "to be a blessing to the nations." in the case of the church … others. And thus, we are judged by higher standards.

On the reading of the prophets, I think you are absolutely right.  And I would add Jesus’ woeful words of judgment on Jerusalem in the Gospels for example. While I do not think there would be many card carrying Christians Zionists in Malaysia (I may be wrong), but popular teaching on "You must bless and not curse Israel" kind of thinking maybe embedded behind a lot of the gut reactions of people.  I was once one of them, so I stand convicted.

On your question on the Malaysian portrayal of the matter, I’m not surprised by the anti-Israel tone especially in the light of selling papers and the elections in KT. Sorry for being a little cynical on that end, I can’t help it as one who grow up with a father involved in advertising.

As mentioned in my first reply, I do not find the "blame" game approach useful in the light of a humanitarian crisis, the fact is if you want to do that both are to be blamed.  The people in power should be blamed as their decisions inflict great pain on people on the borders of Gaza as well as people locked in Gaza now. The debate will wage on while people continue to wage war.

On the role of Arab states, whatever we can say is pure conjecture based on whatever information we are exposed to, allowed to, or filtered through.  So looks like a dead end there too.

On Israel avoiding civilians, I wish it was that easy. This is not a "counter strike" game.

On Hamas propaganda, I do not deny that the likelihood of that to be true at some level.  But then this accusation is the same on the Israeli government.  Do you see where I am going with this?

So, unless we get "pro-accuracy" information as Bro. Pro-accuracy puts it.  I don’t see how our often concerned "coffee shop" analysis can take us forward. In moments of crisis and war like now, looks like there are layers and layers to get through before we will get to the truths of the matter.

Then there is the more personal matter on this, I attribute my empathy to the Palestinian tragedy very much to my Palestinian Pastor friend serving in Jerusalem years ago. And I noticed those who have been to Israel and interacted with Palestinians would tend towards preferring to speak out in solidarity with them while keeping an eye not be prejudice against any thing on Israel.  I do not think it’s easy to articulate that. And it also depends on which issue.

Theologically, when we speak of Christians who takes Christ as the ultimate revelation and fulfillment of God’s vision and intention for the World,  it is working out of that centre first and foremost and throughout one’s thinking.  And then with a good healthy dose of Trinitarian theology and Eschatology which is focuses on the consummation of the history and world in Christ etc., this would be a better framework to see where Israel fits in this schema rather than the other way round.  Of course, this is distinctively a Christian approach (I’m sure there will be those who disagree depending on where one starts and wishes to orientate the theological framework).

2 more cents
Engaged Re-framer

* * *

Dear Engaged Re-framer,

I highly commend this book, which we use at our centre, along with Colin’s Whose Promised Land, Mitri Raheb’s I am a Palestinian Christian, O. Palmer Robertson’s The Israel of God and The Christ of Covenants, Ilan Pappe’s A History of Modern Palestine, and Gary Burge’s Whose Land, Whose Promise.

Bro. Pro-accuracy

* * *

7 thoughts on “Friends in Conversation on “Palestine and Israel” Part II”

  1. Pingback: An E-mail Conversation On Israel-Palestine | bobjots : redux
  2. God's friend says:
    20 January, 2009 at 8:01 pm

    Hey guys, quite an interesting little debate you got going there.

    Before you go any further and start getting theological, I’d like to invite you to look simply at your OT and explain why God was so war-like then and did not seem to exhibit our modern sensibility about war and the killing of what we would now termed “innocent” civilians.

    Was the God of the OT the same God today or not? Ponder over this a bit, and then perhaps you might get to be in a better position to dispense your views about Israel/Palestine issue, instead of merely following the world’s view of current events which are largely influenced by people with varied vested interests.

  3. Bob K says:
    21 January, 2009 at 1:52 am

    Ahh .. the age old question 🙂

    This would really be interesting to follow. Is God a sadistic puppet master? 😀

  4. Bob K says:
    21 January, 2009 at 1:54 am

    Have to wonder though .. how else do we approach this question .. if not theologically.

  5. Bob K says:
    21 January, 2009 at 1:59 am

    Why should we fear a theological answer? Isn’t theology just a means of trying to understand the Scriptures?

  6. Younger Prodigal says:
    21 January, 2009 at 2:01 am

    Hehe, they don’t call them God’s Chosen People for nothing; God chose them to be the embodiment of everything that’s wrong so that others will not make the same mistakes.

    Since the Israelites have been “replaced” by Christians, we should all be fearful that we don’t end up being the bad example this time and the pariah of the world.

    But do we learn? No, we engage in internet discussions (semi)-anonymously so that we can “baling batu, sembunyi tangan” 🙂

  7. alwyn says:
    21 January, 2009 at 1:22 pm

    Dear God’s Friend,

    Thanks for raising this issue. A few comments:

    1. *Even if we have absolutely NO answer*, I think our theology would be better ‘on track’ if we focused on Jesus as the ‘ultimate’ (and OT-clarifying) revelation of the kind of God that God is. If we hold to this and if we read the Gospels and look at the character and actions of Jesus, it would become *very* difficult to justify anything like the violence happening now in Gaza (by any party). Also, I find it significant that the NT writers never used the OT to justify physical violence (and the NT as a whole never condones violence or calls the early church to ‘act in self-defense’, launch pre-emptive strikes, etc, etc.)

    2. OT violence was specific divine judgments against wicked nations (e.g. the Amalekites) which continually terrorized the Hebrews. The ‘take-over’ of Canaanland was *punishment due* to the Canaanites for their detestable practices and sin (virtually all the prohibitions in the OT are counter-responses to the practices ALREADY committed by the people, e.g. bestiality, infant sacrifices, incest, prostitution, etc.) i.e. God was going to judge these people *anyway* but He mercifully decided to not do another Sodom-and-Gomorrah and instructed Israel to chase them out into exile instead.

    The point is: This is VERY different from the situation today in which innocent people are being made to suffer because no other retaliatory response (apart from shelling Hamas venues within Gaza) can be considered.

    3. Finally, consider the LIMITATIONS God gave the Israelites:

    a) They were supposed to make PEACE to the nations at a distance (Deut 20:10-16)
    b) They were ordered to NOT destroy the ‘cities and the buildings'(!), see Deut 6:10
    c) They weren’t even supposed to destroy the vegetation and trees, see Deut 20:19

    Suffice to say, we simply cannot look at the OT violence and a) ignore the message/example of Jesus in order to b) justify the killings of innocents today (for whatever reason).

    Hope this helps,
    Alwyn

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Moved to Medium
  • The End | The Beginning
  • I Will be Back …
  • It’s Been a While …
  • GE13 Malaysia: Who to Vote for? (A Christian Contribution)

Recent Comments

  • Malaysia: Government Vows to Review Web Censorship Law After Protest · Global Voices on STOP 114A: INTERNET BLACKOUT DAY
  • List of Participants in Internet Blackout Day! « #Stop114A on STOP 114A: INTERNET BLACKOUT DAY
  • Join Us and Support Internet Blackout Day « #Stop114A on STOP 114A: INTERNET BLACKOUT DAY
  • JB on Imagining My PhD Journey
  • Alex Tang on Imagining My PhD Journey

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

CALENDAR

January 2009
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  
« Dec   Feb »
  • Academics
  • Bangsar Lutheran Church
  • Beyond
  • Bible
  • Blogging
  • Books
  • Christian Year – Lent
  • Church
  • Conversations
  • Emergent/Emerging Churches
  • Events
  • Family
  • Five Sentences
  • Friends in Conversation
  • Fun stuff
  • Gracious Christianity
  • Ideas
  • Images
  • Leadership
  • Learning
  • Lists
  • Lutheran
  • Lutheran Church in Malaysia & Singapore
  • Malaysia
  • Meditation
  • Micah Mandate
  • Mission
  • Movies
  • Music
  • New Stuff
  • Norway
  • Norwegian Notes
  • Personal
  • Philosophy
  • Podcast
  • Preaching
  • Prezi
  • Project 365
  • Random Links
  • Random Thoughts
  • Random Tweets
  • Random Utterances
  • Religion
  • Resources
  • RoH Malaysia
  • Second Thoughts
  • Seven Series
  • Simple Steps
  • Spirituality
  • Technology
  • Theology
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • World
  • Worship
  • Writing

Archives

  • November 2020
  • November 2014
  • April 2014
  • February 2014
  • April 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • August 2012
  • June 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011
  • June 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
  • December 2010
  • November 2010
  • October 2010
  • September 2010
  • August 2010
  • July 2010
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • June 2009
  • May 2009
  • April 2009
  • March 2009
  • February 2009
  • January 2009
  • December 2008
  • November 2008
  • October 2008
  • September 2008
  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • May 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • December 2007
  • November 2007
  • October 2007
  • September 2007
  • August 2007
  • July 2007
  • June 2007
  • May 2007
  • April 2007
  • March 2007
  • February 2007
  • January 2007
  • December 2006
  • November 2006
  • October 2006
  • September 2006
  • August 2006
  • July 2006
  • June 2006
  • May 2006
  • April 2006
  • March 2006
  • February 2006
  • January 2006
  • December 2005
  • November 2005
  • October 2005
  • September 2005
  • August 2005
  • July 2005
  • June 2005
  • May 2005
  • April 2005
  • March 2005
  • February 2005
  • January 2005
  • December 2004
  • November 2004
  • October 2004
  • September 2004
  • August 2004
  • July 2004
  • June 2004
  • May 2004
  • April 2004
  • March 2004
  • February 2004
  • January 2004
  • December 2003
  • November 2003
  • October 2003
  • September 2003
  • August 2003
  • July 2003
  • June 2003
  • May 2003
  • April 2003
  • February 2003
  • August 2002

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Pages

  • About
  • Church
  • Disclaimer
  • Education
  • Writing

Social Media

© 2022 Sivin Kit's Garden | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme